The most expensive house ever sold on Nantucket recorded in the week of November 5 to 12. Blue Waters, at 57 Hulbert Avenue, was designed by William Edward Shepherd and built in 1937. According to Nantucket Current, it sold for $42.5 million without ever being listed publicly. That beat the island's previous residential record, a $42 million Monomoy compound sold in 2023. It came in just under the $43 million Martha's Vineyard sale in September 2026 that set the state record.
The record arrived after the summer, and that timing is the usual pattern. Each month the Nantucket Land Bank publishes the total value of property transfers recorded on the island. In every year of its recent tables, the largest month is October and the second largest is September. The summer months come next, and late winter and spring trail far behind. A buyer who plans around the seasons is working from a market whose numbers get set in the fall.
Three Octobers in a Row
The Land Bank's figures cover every recorded transfer, including exempt ones, so they measure total money moving through the island's land records. They don't give a price per house. They do show when that money moves.
October 2024 recorded $244.4 million in gross transfer value across 126 transfers, the highest month of the Land Bank's 2025 fiscal year. October 2025 recorded $380.3 million across 123 transfers. October 2026 recorded $281.7 million across 117 transfers, again the high point of the calendar year so far.
Here are the first ten months of the last two years, month by month, from the Land Bank's November 10, 2026 meeting packet:
| Month | 2025 gross transfer value | 2026 gross transfer value |
|---|---|---|
| January | $127.7 million | $111.1 million |
| February | $88.0 million | $63.3 million |
| March | $52.8 million | $98.6 million |
| April | $108.3 million | $39.6 million |
| May | $57.1 million | $80.8 million |
| June | $103.7 million | $100.2 million |
| July | $130.4 million | $117.9 million |
| August | $188.8 million | $156.6 million |
| September | $295.8 million | $249.2 million |
| October | $380.3 million | $281.7 million |
From January through October 2026, September and October together recorded about $531 million of the $1.299 billion total, roughly 41 percent of the year's value in two months. In the same ten months of 2025 the two months came to about $676 million of $1.533 billion, or about 44 percent. In both years the money builds through August and peaks in October.
The Inquirer and Mirror saw the same pattern a year ago. Its October 2025 report counted nearly $278 million across 60 closings in September 2025 and expected another high-dollar October, with high-end sales supporting Land Bank revenue.
What This Fall Actually Recorded
The fall totals come from named houses. Nantucket Current publishes a weekly roundup of recorded transfers, and this September and October list much of what the top of the market looks like.
The roundup for August 27 to September 3, 2026 was led by 15 Deer Run Road at $12 million. Two weeks later, 69 Monomoy Road recorded at $19.5 million, alongside 6 Gull Island Lane at $9.375 million and 4 Gay Street at $8.5 million. In early October, 67 Vestal Street sold for $11.25 million and 43 Vestal Street for $7.3 million in the same week. The following week 4 Black Walnut Lane recorded at $11.995 million.
The heaviest week came at the end of October. Between October 22 and 29, 5 Grant Avenue sold for $35 million, 94 Main Street for $15.25 million and 5 Pilgrim Road for $10.75 million. Nantucket Current's roundup for that week noted that this was the third sale of 5 Grant Avenue since 2022.
Blue Waters recorded in the November 5 to 12 window, the same week 25 North Pasture Lane sold for $10.25 million and 7 Van Fleet Circle for $6.75 million. That puts the island's biggest sale of the year in the month after the October peak.
A Lighter Year With the Same Shape
The 2026 numbers are smaller than 2025's. Gross transfer value from January through October 2026 was about 15 percent below the same ten months of 2025. Taxable transfers, the transactions that pay the Land Bank fee, fell from 406 to 316 over that stretch. October 2026 came in about 26 percent below October 2025.
The calendar held anyway. In a slower year, September and October still produced the two largest months, and April produced the smallest at $39.6 million, with only 16 taxable transfers on the island that month. The fall peak doesn't depend on a strong year. In 2025 and in 2026, a year with about 15 percent less value, the recorded deeds still clustered in September and October.
What the Calendar Does to Your Comparables
This timing matters most to a buyer who studies the market before acting. Comparable sales are recorded transactions, and on Nantucket the two largest months of recorded value, by a wide margin, are September and October. A buyer studying recent sales in January or March is reading a record whose heaviest months came the previous fall.
Winter adds little new information. In 2026, January, February and March recorded between $63.3 million and $111.1 million each, against $281.7 million in October. A spring month with 16 taxable transfers can't say much about where a particular street or price tier is heading. Any average from that month depends heavily on which few houses happened to record.
For a buyer looking at Vestal Street or Monomoy this winter, the fall's recorded sales are a large share of the recent evidence. On Vestal Street, two houses sold in a single October week, at $11.25 million and $7.3 million, and on Monomoy Road one sold for $19.5 million in mid-September.
Sellers face the same timing from the other side. The months with the most new sales data are September and October, so when an owner decides to sell and when the record fills in with fresh sales run on separate calendars.
The Sales That Never Appear as Listings
The fall peak has one more feature. Some of the largest transactions never show up as a listing at all. Blue Waters was not publicly listed before it closed, and both agents involved declined to comment beyond the sale, citing nondisclosure agreements, according to Nantucket Current. The buyer was recorded as Stella Blue Waters, LLC.
So the record price for a Nantucket house first became public when the sale closed, with no public asking price beforehand. At the top of this market, the public record is often the first public trace of a sale. A buyer who follows only active listings will see these transactions after they have closed, and a seller weighing a private sale should know that the comparison set includes trades like this one.
For anyone who owns on the island, the fall is busy in other ways too, as our look at what stays open on Nantucket in the fall describes. The island's largest months of recorded sales fall in those same weeks.
If you are planning a purchase or sale on Nantucket for next season, we would be glad to go through this fall's recorded sales with you, street by street, before the spring listings arrive. The Robinette Team can prepare a private valuation built on the September and October sales that will anchor next year's pricing. Request a Private Valuation.