Search
Weathered cedar-shingle house entrance with a deep blue door, cream trim, granite steps and faded hydrangea flowers.

Nantucket Short-Term Rental Rules: What Buyers Must Check

When a Nantucket house sells, its rental certificate does not go with it. The town code says the registration "is issued to the operator and does not run with the land," and a new owner has to file a new application before guests can return.

This matters more now because the island-wide zoning fight is nearly over. The rules about who may operate a short-term rental have not changed. A buyer who pays for a proven rental is really buying a house plus an application, and how they take title can decide whether that application is allowed at all.

The zoning vote moved the question indoors

For several years the main uncertainty was whether short-term rentals were legal under Nantucket zoning. In May 2025, Annual Town Meeting rejected all four rental articles. Article 66, the by-right proposal, won 468 to 321, short of the two-thirds it needed. Land Court Judge Michael Vhay then ruled that the bylaw did not allow rentals under 31 days of a primary dwelling in the Residential Old Historic district, except for renting rooms in an owner-occupied home. The ruling was limited to that district.

The November 4, 2025 Special Town Meeting changed that. Article 1, a citizen petition from charter captain Brian Borgeson, passed 1,045 to 421, or 71 percent. It makes short- and long-term rentals principal uses by right in every district except Commercial Industrial. It also makes short-term rental use expressly subject to Town Code Chapters 123 and 338. Voters took no action on Article 2, Planning Board chair Dave Iverson's competing proposal. It would have capped rentals at 49 days between June 15 and August 31 and 70 days a year. After the vote, the Town and the Grapes withdrew the Town's appeal in the Ward case. The Appeals Court dismissed it with prejudice on November 10, 2025.

Attorney General Andrea Campbell's office approved the bylaw on May 18, 2026. Attorney Nina Pickering-Cook, representing an unnamed resident, had argued it repeated articles that failed earlier. Assistant Attorney General Kelli Gunagan wrote that Article 1 and the earlier articles "contain enough differences that they do not constitute identical proposals." The May 2026 Annual Town Meeting had no rental articles on its warrant.

One step remains open. The Inquirer and Mirror reported that the bylaw takes effect once the town finishes posting and publishing it under state law. We could not find a public record confirming that step as of early October 2026. Any buyer relying on the zoning change should ask counsel to confirm its status. Either way, the zoning question now affects fewer transactions than the operator rules in Chapter 123, and those rules apply today.

Three clauses that decide what a buyer actually acquires

Chapter 123 began at the 2022 Annual Town Meeting as Article 39. The parts that matter most in a sale were added in 2024. Each of the three below follows from the one before.

The certificate stays with the operator. This is the clause quoted at the top. It means rental eligibility is reviewed again at every change of ownership, so the buyer is the one the Board of Health evaluates.

The buyer's ownership form is screened. Section 123-3H bars short-term rentals in units owned by "a corporation, partnership, real estate investment trust, or any similar entity which pools funds from investors and is engaged primarily in investment activity." The definitions are broad. "Corporation" covers any entity taxable as a corporation under the Internal Revenue Code, including LLCs taxed as corporations and Massachusetts Business Trusts. An LLC or S corporation escapes that definition only "when every shareholder, partner, and member is a natural person." The applicant has to document that at registration and again later as the regulations require. A multi-member LLC taxed as a partnership qualifies under the same natural-person test. This language came from two votes. Article 60 at the May 2024 Annual Town Meeting, a Select Board compromise, passed 592 to 545. Article 5 at the September 2024 Special Town Meeting passed 544 to 143 and extended the corporate definition to entities treated as corporations for federal tax purposes.

A seller's grandfathered status ends at the sale. Section 123-3K exempts owners from the entity ban if they paid room excise tax before January 1, 2024 and owned the property before May 7, 2024. That includes LLCs, trusts and S corporations, but excludes corporations. The exemption lasts "until the dwelling unit is transferred or conveyed," or until the certificate lapses or is revoked. Inheritance through a will or trust is the stated exception. Former Select Board member Bruce Miller proposed the revised grandfather wording.

Taken together, a house can be rented legally for years under a structure the next owner may not use. The seller's setup tells a buyer almost nothing about their own eligibility.

Seller's situation What happens at the sale Buyer's starting point
Individual owner with a current certificate Certificate stays with the seller New application before any rental
Grandfathered LLC, trust or S corporation Exemption ends on conveyance Buyer's own entity must pass §123-3H
Owner whose certificate lapsed or was revoked Grandfather status already gone Same as any new operator
Owner who dies and leaves the property by will or trust Bequest exception applies Heir may continue under §123-3K
Income-restricted or affordable unit Rentals barred regardless of owner Not eligible

The last row comes from §123-3I, which prohibits short-term rentals in units under an affordability restriction or receiving housing assistance. Section 123-3J similarly bars timeshare and interval-ownership units, but it exempts families and noncommercial groups that hold and transfer property among themselves rather than on the open market.

What the new operator's application requires

A buyer who passes the entity test still needs a certificate of registration before the first booking. The Board of Health regulations were last amended in full on March 19, 2026. The application calls for:

  • ownership and unit details, plus a Massachusetts Department of Revenue certificate
  • a local designated person who can address issues within two hours
  • at least $1 million in liability coverage, unless a hosting platform provides equal or greater coverage
  • a $250 registration fee per unit

Once registered, the operator must cap occupancy at two people per bedroom plus two. The registration number has to appear in all advertising, renters must be given emergency, waste, noise and lighting information, and the operator must keep three years of stay and tax records and file quarterly listing reports. The Board may inspect on reasonable notice, by consent or administrative warrant.

Under Nantucket Town Code Chapter 123, certificates last one year. Renewal applications and the annual fee are due by November 1, with an attestation that the rental followed town bylaws and regulations during the prior year. As of today, that deadline is four weeks away. A seller who lets the certificate lapse during a listing also gives up grandfather status, since §123-3K ends the exemption on nonrenewal.

The tax layer a buyer's projections should carry

According to Mass.gov, Massachusetts charges a 5.7 percent room occupancy excise statewide. Communities may add up to 6 percent in local room tax and, for qualifying rentals, a community impact fee of up to 3 percent. Nantucket's fee schedule, effective October 1, 2024, lists a 6 percent local excise and a 3 percent community impact fee. The impact fee applies only to qualifying categories, which include professionally managed units, so it may not apply to every owner. State registration is required even for a few days of renting. An operator who rents 14 days or fewer in a calendar year can claim an exemption by January 15. Once rentals pass 14 days, tax is due on the first 14 as well.

The money involved is substantial. Nantucket Current reported short-term rental occupancy tax receipts of just under $4.4 million for summer 2025, up 24 percent from summer 2024 but about 9 percent below the 2023 record. Year-to-date 2026 receipts were running about 11 percent ahead of the same period in 2025. We found no local data showing that rental eligibility raises or lowers sale prices. A buyer pricing in rental income is pricing in their own future certificate, not the seller's.

Before the purchase and sale agreement

The order matters, because the entity question is cheap to settle before the deed is drafted and expensive after.

  1. Decide how title will be held, and have counsel check that structure against the corporation and partnership definitions in Chapter 123.
  2. Ask the seller whether the property's rental history depends on the §123-3K grandfather clause. If it does, that history won't carry over.
  3. Confirm whether the unit carries an affordability restriction or interval-ownership arrangement.
  4. Line up the local designated person and the $1 million liability coverage before closing, so the application can be filed right away.
  5. If the property already has bookings, work out with the seller and counsel how those stays will be handled while the new application is pending.

None of this is legal or tax advice, and an attorney familiar with Nantucket should review any entity structure. Every item on the list comes straight from the code.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a buyer keep a seller's existing rental bookings? Under §123-3G, rentals can continue or resume only after the new operator files a new application. Any booking that runs past closing needs to be dealt with in the purchase agreement.

Does buying through an LLC rule out renting? Not automatically. An LLC qualifies when every member is a natural person and that is documented. An LLC with an entity as a member, or one structured as an investor pool, falls under the §123-3H prohibition.

Is the November 2025 zoning bylaw in effect? The Attorney General approved it on May 18, 2026, and it takes effect after the town's posting and publication. We could not confirm those steps were completed, so check the current status with the town or counsel.

What if the property is inherited? Section 123-3K lets a beneficiary who receives the property by will, trust or similar instrument continue renting under that section.

If you own a grandfathered rental and are thinking about selling, or you're buying and want title structured before an offer, The Robinette Team can go through the Chapter 123 issues with you and your counsel early. Request a Private Valuation that accounts for what a buyer will actually be able to do with the property.

Work With Us

With 25 years of combined real estate experience, both Curran and Gabby are leading experts in their field, working with the most discerning clientele to achieve the highest price possible for sellers and sourcing impossible-to-find properties for buyers, in addition to servicing investors and consulting on development.

Follow Me on Instagram